Critique: MICON / M1
Birmingham, Gupta, Siewiorek
*
Despite being an impressive system, many of the finer details concerning
design were lost among the technical jargon of the hardware world.
I would imagine the paper to be of great interest to someone who works
in the domain presented. In fact, it would seem as
though this paper is a start to position M1 (and MICON) for commercial
release.
How M1 approaches what appears to be a configuration task
became more clear after a second reading. A presentation of M1's
framework apart from the specific application it was used for would
have been much appreciated. The detailed examples given were lost on
me, having only a basic understanding of integrated circuit design.
It would be interesting to see the M1 approach applied to another
domain. For example, M1's handling of physical constraints
demonstrates it might be successful in mechanical design.
*
W. Birmingham, A. Gupta & D. Siewiorek. (1992).
Automating the Design of Computer Systems:
The MICON Project, Jones & Bartlett Publishers.
|