Critique: Issues in Multiagent Design Systems
Lander
*
In Lander's introduction to Agent technologies she uses the terms
"agency" and
"agent". The manner in which this is done implies the terms are
interchangeable though logic suggests they are not. While both terms'
definitions are said to be incomplete and debated, little clarification
is offered.
Later on, Lander takes a broad view of agency. The characteristics she
notes seem to be related to an agent. An agency seems more related
to a function or a group of individuals providing some function than
to a single component. Yet, based on Lander's statements, one can only
conclude she means the terms agency and agent to be synonymous.
I was surprised that XML was not mentioned as a communication language
in addition to KQML, KIF, etc. Although XML is more general in purpose,
it seems to serve the goals of the other languages mentioned. XML
was around in 1996 (see
www.oasis-open.org/cover/xml.html
for details) but maybe it wasn't widely known about in 1997 outside of
web and database worlds.
The description of the coordination mechanism "Narrowing the search
space" sounds very much like Lander's and Lesser's work in "Customizing
Distributed Search among Agents with Heterogeneous Knowledge" but it is
cited under "Explicit control representation". Since Lander was an author
of the cited work, I can only assume she knows where best to categorize
it, but I found the explanations unsatisfying.
Overall, this was an interesting overview of agent based systems.
It did not provide a great deal of technical information
though. It seems best used to peek one's interest in multiagent systems
and provide pointers to more information rather than providing a useful
background of the subject. Since the title indicates the article
will speak of issues in these systems, the article does seem to be
true to its intent. The list of questions, or issues, the article
presents are interesting but of limited use without some background
knowledge of multiagent system, which the article does not provide.
This is inconsistent with the beginning of the article which seems to
try to be an introduction to multiagent systems.
*
Susan E. Lander, Blackboard Technology,
Issues in Multiagent Design Systems,
in IEEE Expert, March-April 1997
|